
Love Me with Lies
romantic suspense
Series · psychological thriller
The Brenna Spector series by Alison Gaylin has 3 books and is best read in publication order, starting with And She Was (2012).
Start here: And She Was (2012) — then read straight through in publication order.
The order the books were released — the default way to read the series.
The Brenna Spector novels follow a Westchester County private investigator with a rare neurological condition, hyperthymestic syndrome, that lets her recall almost every day of her life in perfect, unwanted detail -- a gift that makes her superb at finding missing people and unbearable when the memories that surface are her own. Brenna's ability first became a curse seventeen years earlier, when her sister Clea vanished as a teenager and Brenna, watching from a few feet away, has replayed the moment ever since without ever fully understanding it.
Across the trilogy, Alison Gaylin uses Brenna's condition as both investigative tool and emotional trap: cases about other people's missing children and buried secrets keep circling back to Brenna's own unresolved grief over Clea, and each book chips further at what actually happened that day. The tone sits at the harder-edged end of psychological suspense -- grief, trauma, and the unreliability of even perfect memory are constant themes -- and the series won critical attention for its unusual, well-researched central conceit. It's a complete, self-contained trilogy: Gaylin closes Brenna's core mystery by the third book rather than leaving it open-ended.
Three: And She Was (2012), Into the Dark (2013), and Stay With Me (2014).
Publication order. The mystery of Brenna's missing sister Clea, introduced in And She Was, develops across all three books and resolves by the end of the trilogy.
A real (if extremely rare) neurological condition in which a person can recall almost every day of their life in vivid detail. Brenna's version of it is central to both her skill as an investigator and her inability to move past her sister's disappearance.
Yes, it's a complete trilogy. Alison Gaylin resolves Brenna's core family mystery by the end of Stay With Me and has not continued the series since.
Yes -- the two-book Samantha Leiffer mysteries and two-book Simone Glass mysteries, plus standalone thrillers, all tracked on her author page, and she has written recent Robert B. Parker's Sunny Randall continuation novels.
Reading order last verified .